Explore key takeaways and evaluations of significant energy-related books published in 2018, highlighting historical context and future implications.
An inventor, fracking, history and the future.
As we approach the end of the year, it's time to look back at some noteworthy energy books published in 2018. This review aims to provide insights into each book’s contributions to the discourse on energy and its historical significance, helping you decide which to add to your reading list.
Energy: A Human History by Richard Rhodes
Energy: A Human History by Richard Rhodes is a comprehensive examination of energy through the ages. Rhodes covers the critical transition from wood to coal, detailing how coal mining spurred advancements in steam engine technology initially designed for water extraction from mines. Following this, he transitions to the oil era, marking the decline of the whaling industry and the emergence of electricity.
In the latter sections, Rhodes delves into 20th-century issues such as air pollution, nuclear energy, and initial ventures into solar and wind power. While his research is thorough, some readers may find the narrative somewhat overwhelming as it often reads like a series of factual presentations rather than an engaging storyline. For instance, he mentions the mysterious assassination of a key inventor in gas lamp technology without offering further context, leaving a sense of disconnect.
Moreover, while technical descriptions and diagrams, such as those explaining uranium fission, might appeal to some, others may perceive the detail as overemphasizing textbook style at the expense of engaging storytelling. Although there are intriguing historical perspectives, like a journalist's incredulous reaction to fast train travel, the book sometimes lacks a compelling central arc, as noted by critics in outlets such as the Washington Post.
Tesla: Inventor of the Modern by Richard Munson
In stark contrast to Rhodes' approach, Tesla: Inventor of the Modern by Richard Munson offers a narrative-driven exploration of Nikola Tesla’s life and contributions. Tesla, often celebrated as history's greatest inventor, is known for groundbreaking advancements in radio, robotics, remote control, electric motors, and alternating current (AC) electricity.
Munson effectively integrates Tesla's own writings, emphasizing his enthusiasm and unique character, while maintaining a balanced perspective, albeit teetering on the edge of hagiography. Delving into Tesla's rivalry with Thomas Edison, particularly in the AC versus direct current debate, Munson unpacks Edison's controversial tactics, including the electric chair’s use to demonize AC electricity.
Moreover, Tesla’s financial difficulties towards the end of his life serve as a poignant reminder of the economic challenges often faced by brilliant innovators. His lack of commercial success contrasts sharply with his plethora of visionary ideas, as he is remembered primarily for his impactful inventions rather than those that never materialized.
Saudi America: The Truth About Fracking and How It’s Changing the World by Bethany McLean
Next is Saudi America by Bethany McLean. Given McLean's successful track record with her Enron exposé, The Smartest Guys in the Room, my expectations were high. Regrettably, this book underwhelms, presenting itself more as a brief pamphlet than a well-developed discussion, at just 131 pages.
Lacking a clear argumentative structure, the book appears to insinuate deceit or incompetence regarding fracking investments, particularly in light of historically low interest rates. From my perspective, this seems unfairly critical of standard economic behavior in energy markets. A review from the Wall Street Journal echoed these sentiments, pointing out similar disappointments with the thematic development of the book.
The Wizard and the Prophet by Charles C. Mann
Charles C. Mann’s The Wizard and the Prophet, which I haven’t personally read yet but received positive feedback on, contrasts two influential figures in sustainability: William Vogt, an early environmentalist, and Norman Borlaug, whose work catalyzed the Green Revolution with significant increases in crop yields, especially in developing nations.
The book’s premise outlines Vogt's beliefs in the necessity for limiting population and consumption versus Borlaug's belief in technology-based solutions to enhance food production capabilities. This dichotomy frames a broader discussion, although critics note it can be a bit simplistic in addressing complex interactions, such as those involved in renewable energy. Still, Mann's exploration broadens understanding of historical approaches to addressing humanity's impending challenges.
As I prepare to shift gears into reading Michelle Obama’s autobiography, Becoming, I hope it meets the high expectations it has generated. Your thoughts and recommendations on additional titles would be appreciated!
